Labour blocks Reform bid to protect planning powers
Ipswich Labour councillors used their majority at Wednesday's Full Council meeting to replace a Reform UK motion demanding a review of new government planning rules with an amendment backing the changes instead.
Why it matters: New government regulations have changed who decides planning applications across England, limiting when ward councillors can refer contentious cases – including some House in Multiple Occupation (HMO) conversions – to the Planning and Development Committee for public debate.
The details: At the meeting on Wednesday, 18 November, Reform UK Councillor Richard Foster (Gipping Ward) tabled a motion calling on the council to demand a review or repeal of the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026.
The regulations, which came into force on 31 October, divide planning applications into two categories:
- Schedule 1 – householder, minor commercial and minor residential applications, including standard HMO conversions, which must be decided by a planning officer.
- Schedule 2 – all other applications, where officer determination is presumed unless a nominated officer and a nominated committee member jointly agree to refer it to committee.
Labour councillor Carole Jones moved an amendment replacing Foster's motion in full. It states that the government is "correct" to bring in the changes, and calls for the government's planned review of the system to take place in 2027 rather than 2028 – but does not call for the regulations to be repealed.
Following a recorded vote requested by Reform UK, every Labour councillor present voted for the amendment, defeating Foster's motion.
What they're saying: Cllr Foster said: "Tonight, Ipswich Labour had a simple choice: stand up for the residents who elected them, or protect their party colleagues in Westminster from embarrassment. Shamefully, every single Labour councillor chose their party over Ipswich.
"Not only did Labour use their majority to gut my motion and drop our call to repeal these undemocratic rules, they actually voted to put on the official record that the Labour government is 'correct' to strip power away from local planning committees.
"Even though Labour's own amendment admits Ipswich's Planning Committee is well-run, they have meekly accepted a system where local councillors are locked out of HMO decisions and unelected officers hold a veto over major developments.
"Reform UK forced a recorded vote tonight so that every resident across Gipping and the rest of Ipswich can see in black and white who stood up for local democracy, and who blindly followed party orders."
The other side: Cllr Jones said the amendment addressed "a number of deficiencies" in Foster's motion, arguing it failed to acknowledge that more than 90% of planning decisions in Ipswich are already taken by officers without going to committee, meaning the changes will affect "only a relatively small number of applications."
She said a bigger erosion of democratic accountability happened under the previous government, when extended permitted development rights removed the ability of both councillors and officers to refuse some applications.
Cllr Jones said the amendment recognised why ministers had acted, pointing to evidence that, although Ipswich is a well-run planning authority, around 70% of councils nationally do not have up-to-date Local Plans. She added there is anecdotal evidence that some planning committees reject applications against officer advice to avoid accountability, "while knowing full well that this will get overturned on appeal," which she said costs taxpayers millions of pounds a year.
She also said the amendment backs a call from the Local Government Association to bring forward the government's planned review of the new system from 2028 to 2027, and dismissed suggestions that decision-making was being taken away from Ipswich as "nonsense," since planning decisions will continue to be made locally under Local Plan policies set by Ipswich councillors.
What's next: The amendment resolves to ask the Leader of the Council to write to the Minister for Housing, Communities and Local Government and the MP for Ipswich, setting out the council's position on how Schedule 1 of the regulations applies.
The bottom line: Labour and Reform UK clashed over how much the new rules actually change in Ipswich, with Reform calling it an attack on local democracy and Labour arguing the impact will be limited and that the government's intervention is a response to problems seen elsewhere in local government, not in Ipswich.
Don't forget: If you enjoy our content, please add Ipswich.co.uk as a "preferred source" on Google so you can easily find more of the content you value.
This article cost us ~£54 to produce
It's free for you to read thanks to the generous support of our partners. Please support us by supporting them.
Below the line