Skip to main contentEnter
Purposeful journalism for people who care about our town
Ipswich.co.uk logoSupport our work
Opinion

The verdict on Kalvin Phillips as Town close marquee signing

To much adulation, Kalvin Phillips has joined Town on a season-long loan. We weigh up the pros and cons of this statement signing.

The big picture: With 73 top-flight games under his belt, Phillips could play a crucial role in solidifying Ipswich's midfield as they aim to establish themselves in the Premier League under Kieran McKenna.

The 28-year-old also has 31 England caps and won the fan-voted 2020-21 BT England men's player of the year award. His last international appearance came in November 2023.

Kalvin Phillips warming up for Manchester City
Kalvin Phillips warming up for Manchester City(Alamy)

Why it matters: Ipswich's Premier League survival hopes could be significantly boosted by Phillips' proven ability at the highest level.

Town reportedly faced stiff competition from established Premier League clubs Fulham and Everton for his signature. It's a testament to the club's hierarchy that the deal has progressed this far, with Sky Sports reporting that Phillips was impressed with the project after discussions with boss Kieran McKenna and chairman Mark Ashton.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

By the numbers: According to Opta, over the past 365 days, Phillips averages: 

  • 2.80 tackles per 90 minutes (87th percentile)

  • 62.80 passes attempted per 90 (79th percentile)

  • 85.0% pass completion rate (62nd percentile)

  • 1.81 aerials won per 90 (88th percentile)

On the pitch: Phillips' defensive skills and ball distribution align well with McKenna's tactical approach, potentially providing a stable midfield base and the passing ability to help the team break between the lines. 

He showed promise during Man City's pre-season tour, impressing as an unorthodox centre-back against Barcelona and Chelsea. 

Yes, but: Phillips comes with risks. Ipswich needs high-profile signings to make an immediate impact, yet Phillips' recent record raises concerns. At Manchester City, he made just two league starts, 14 sub appearances, and featured in 10 cup matches, including seven in the Champions League. His loan spell at West Ham was equally underwhelming, with only three starts and five substitute appearances, picking up one red card.

On affordability and value for money: Phillips' reported £150,000-per-week wages present a significant financial challenge. While City may cover a portion of his salary, the deal remains a substantial investment for Town. To justify this outlay, Phillips would need to quickly establish himself as one of the club's top performers.

The bottom line: A gamble worth taking. Phillips could be the experienced anchor Ipswich needs to compete effectively in the Premier League, offering both defensive solidity and the ability to initiate attacks from deep.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

You can read it for free thanks to the generous support of Insight Energy

Despite a lack of promotion, the big reveal drew a good crowd of passersby

We're regenerating Ipswich – but we can't do it without you!

People tell us every day that our work matters – that it's making Ipswich better; that it's needed. But our work costs money, and unlike the Ipswich Star, we're not funded by national advertisers or owned by corporate US overlords. For just £4.75 a month, you can help fund our mission to restore pride of place and accelerate the much-needed regeneration of the town we call home.
Become a member →

In other news...

News

Suffolk charity prepares 100 Christmas dinners for homeless

Staff and service users at Anglia Care Trust prepared 100 full Christmas dinners for rough sleepers and people in temporary accommodation across Ipswich, tripling the charity's original plan after receiving substantial donations.
by
Continue reading →
News

Traders plan more themed markets after festive success

Independent traders in The Walk and Buttermarket are planning more themed street markets next year after a festive vintage event drew significant footfall to the town centre.
by
Continue reading →
News

'Lost for words': Snap Fitness donates 200 toys to hospital

A Martlesham gym manager who spent years in Ipswich Hospital's paediatric ward as a child has delivered over 200 toys, ensuring every young patient receives their own gift on Christmas Day.
by
Continue reading →
News

Five months of Sproughton Road delays for Eastern Gateway

Drivers face five months of disruption on Sproughton Road from January 2026 as work begins on a new roundabout for the Eastern Gateway business park, Ipswich Borough Council has announced.
by
Continue reading →
News

Cyber security programme approves first local projects

A new cyber security programme has received more than 150 expressions of interest from local businesses – almost three times its target – as it approves its first eight projects.
by
Continue reading →
News

Free solar panels and heat pumps available for Suffolk homes

Low-income Suffolk residents living in poorly insulated homes could be eligible for free solar panels, heat pumps and insulation worth thousands of pounds – but must apply within the next three months.
by
Continue reading →
Load more content
This article is free to read thanks to
Want our best content delivered to your inbox every Friday?

Have you subscribed to our free weekly newsletter?

If you haven’t, you really should. You’ll get our best content delivered to your inbox every Friday afternoon, just in time for the weekend. You can unsubscribe at any time, although 99.7% of people don’t.

  • Lee Walker
  • Joe Bailey of Brighten the Corners
  • Mark Hubert
6,970+ people are already loving it