Skip to main contentEnter
Purposeful journalism for people who care about our town
Ipswich.co.uk logoSupport our journalism
News

Suffolk councillors divided over lifting two-child benefit cap

County councillors have passed a motion criticising Government budget measures, including the lifting of the controversial two-child benefit cap, despite a former Ipswich MP dismissing it as "party political grandstanding".

Endeavour House in Ipswich
Oliver Rouane-WilliamsIpswich.co.uk
Endeavour House in Ipswich

Why it matters: Suffolk County Council will now formally write to the county's MPs and Chancellor Rachel Reeves to set out its criticisms of the Government's approach to tackling child poverty.

The details: Cllr Richard Smith, the county's lead for finance, put forward the motion during a council meeting on Thursday, warning the Government's budget, announced by Rachel Reeves last month, would "encourage lethargy" and leave Suffolk worse off.

The motion criticised measures relating to council funding, the hospitality sector and benefits, with councillors of all parties broadly in agreement on these points, particularly around the struggling hospitality sector.

However, opposition to lifting the two-child benefit cap divided councillors.

The debate: Getting rid of the cap was one of the Government's key measures, meant to lift some 450,000 children out of poverty by 2030 at a cost of £3 billion a year.

Conservative councillors argued that encouraging people to work would be a better way to achieve that goal.

Cllr Richard Rout, a former finance lead, but now spearheading the One Suffolk campaign, said the new generation should not grow up thinking "living off the state is more rewarding than going to work".

"We lift children out of poverty by supporting business, growing the economy and creating jobs, not by the endless growth of the welfare state," he said.

Cllr Bobby Bennett, lead for children's services, stressed limited resources would be better off invested in childcare, employment and education.

She said: "[Lifting the cap] may well alleviate the financial pressure for some families, I do not deny that, and children should not be penalised for family size, but this is a handout, not a hand up. I really do have concerns that it will not address the root of the problem. I remain sceptical that this will not support the people that need it most."

The other side: Opposition councillors denounced these criticisms.

Cllr Annette Dunning, spokesperson for the Green, Lib Dem and Independent Group, said: "It makes absolute economic sense to help those children from families claiming support to have the ability to achieve their full potential.

"Children should not be punished for their parents' financial circumstances."

She proposed amending the motion, maintaining everything apart from the criticism of lifting the cap, but this was rejected by the monitoring officer.

Cllr Adele Cook, of the Labour Group, said: "Poverty colleagues, not frivolous expenditure – the poverty the children in this country are living in.

"Not my child, not your children, perhaps not your grandchildren, but children in this country live in poverty, and that's a shame we all carry."

Cllr Christopher Hudson, leader of the Reform Group, said: "I'm not in favour of waste, I am in favour of helping our demographic.

"I want them to be able to work, I want them to be able to raise families, and I want them to be able to receive money for that privilege."

What's next: With the amendment failing before it could be debated, the motion was approved as originally drafted with 32 votes for, 19 against and three abstentions.

Cllr Sandy Martin, former Ipswich MP and leader of the Labour Group, called the motion nothing more than "party political grandstanding".

The bottom line: Despite Labour's Martin dismissing the motion as political posturing, the council has formally committed to writing to Suffolk's MPs and the Chancellor to express its concerns about the Government's budget measures and approach to child poverty.

It cost us ~£27 to produce this article

Our content is free to read thanks to the generous support of GBS , Ipswich School and All About Hearing

GBS logo

GBS

This family-run construction company has delivered quality services across commercial building, fire protection, diamond drilling, health and safety, and asbestos removal for over 30 years.
Russell Osman having his ears checked by All About Hearing audiologist and co-director, Karen Finch

Exceptional hearing care with a personal touch

Suffolk’s independent hearing specialists, combining expert care, cutting-edge technology and personalised service to help you hear at your best.
News

Free training courses launched to get Suffolk working

More than 30 free training courses have been launched in Suffolk to help workers and businesses gain skills in sectors including construction, healthcare and clean energy.
by
Continue reading →
News

Ensors expands Ipswich office amid recruitment drive

One of East Anglia's oldest accountancy firms has expanded its Ipswich office with new workspaces, meeting rooms and an outdoor deck as business growth drives recruitment.
by
Continue reading →
News

500 students try CPR and VR at Ipswich NHS careers fair

Hundreds of students practised CPR on medical training dummies, tried virtual reality headsets at a radiotherapy stand and competed in a 30-second 'Sit to Stand' fitness challenge as an NHS careers fair brought hands-on healthcare demonstrations to Trinity Park.
by
Continue reading →
News

Man charged with eight offences after Burrell Road hit-and-run

A 32-year-old Ipswich man has been charged with eight offences, including causing serious injury by dangerous driving, drink-driving and driving without a license, after a woman was left in a critical condition following a hit-and-run collision on Burrell Road last Thursday morning.
by
Continue reading →
News

SEN Santa sessions at Buttermarket this weekend

Santa will turn down the music and limit numbers at the Buttermarket Shopping Centre this weekend after parents asked for calmer festive events for children with special educational needs (SEN).
by
Continue reading →

GBS , Ipswich School and All About Hearing

GBS logo

GBS

This family-run construction company has delivered quality services across commercial building, fire protection, diamond drilling, health and safety, and asbestos removal for over 30 years.
Russell Osman having his ears checked by All About Hearing audiologist and co-director, Karen Finch

Exceptional hearing care with a personal touch

Suffolk’s independent hearing specialists, combining expert care, cutting-edge technology and personalised service to help you hear at your best.
News

Suffolk researchers test whether singing can treat Parkinson's 'poker face'

Researchers in Suffolk are launching what they believe is the first UK study testing whether musical-theatre-style singing can rehabilitate facial expression in Parkinson's patients – addressing a symptom that affects around 9 in 10 people but has limited treatment options.
by
Continue reading →
News

Woman fighting for life after hit-and-run on Burrell Road

A woman is in a life-threatening condition in hospital after being hit by a car whose driver fled the scene on Burrell Road in Ipswich this morning, with a man in his 30s now arrested in connection with the incident.
by
Continue reading →

GBS , Ipswich School and All About Hearing

GBS logo

GBS

This family-run construction company has delivered quality services across commercial building, fire protection, diamond drilling, health and safety, and asbestos removal for over 30 years.
Russell Osman having his ears checked by All About Hearing audiologist and co-director, Karen Finch

Exceptional hearing care with a personal touch

Suffolk’s independent hearing specialists, combining expert care, cutting-edge technology and personalised service to help you hear at your best.
News

Gym manager's childhood inspires hospital toy appeal

A Martlesham gym manager who spent much of her childhood in hospital has launched a toy appeal that has collected nearly 150 Christmas gifts for young patients at Ipswich Hospital.
by
Continue reading →
Load more content
0:00
0:00
Our content is free to read thanks to
Our content is free to read thanks to
Our content is free to read thanks to
Want our best content delivered to your inbox every Friday?

Have you subscribed to our free weekly newsletter?

If you haven’t, you really should. You’ll get our best content delivered to your inbox every Friday afternoon, just in time for the weekend. You can unsubscribe at any time, although 99.7% of people don’t.

  • Lee Walker
  • Joe Bailey of Brighten the Corners
  • Mark Hubert
6,630+ people are already loving it